Program Evaluation Framework
Mayflower Church Program Evaluation Framework
A Simple, Relational, and Repeatable Process
Purpose
This framework provides a simple and relational approach to program evaluation that aligns with values-based leadership principles. Drawing from Dennis Bakke's philosophy in Joy at Work, this process emphasizes empowerment, shared values, and quality of ministry life over purely quantitative metrics.
Core Principles
Relational over transactional: Evaluation happens through two-way conversations, not one-way reporting
Values-based assessment: Focus on living out our core values rather than achieving purely numerical goals
Quality of ministry life: Success is measured by spiritual health and freedom to use gifts and talents
Simple and sustainable: The process must be easy to implement and maintain without creating bureaucratic burden
Empowerment-focused: Evaluation helps people grow and thrive rather than merely judging performance
What Is a Program?
A program is a structured ministry activity with the following characteristics:
Intentional design: Has clear purpose and objectives aligned with church mission and vision
Regular occurrence: Happens on a recurring basis (weekly, monthly, seasonally, annually)
Resource commitment: Requires dedicated time, people, space, or budget
Designated leadership: Has identified leaders or coordinators responsible for its execution
Measurable outcomes: Has identifiable spiritual or relational outcomes (though not always numerical)
Examples: Discipleship groups, children's ministry, worship services, community outreach initiatives, mission trips, youth programming, adult education classes, care ministry.
The Evaluation Process
This four-phase approach creates a simple, repeatable cycle:
Phase 1: Planning
Key Questions:
What is the program's purpose and how does it align with our church mission?
What spiritual outcomes are we hoping to see in people's lives?
What resources (people, time, budget, space) are needed?
Who are the key leaders and what gifts/talents will they use?
Phase 2: Implementation
Key Questions:
Are people experiencing joy and finding meaning in this ministry?
Are leaders empowered to make decisions and use their talents?
Are relationships being built and nurtured?
What barriers are people facing in their spiritual growth through this program?
Phase 3: Evaluation
Use the Checkup Loop approach: regular two-way conversations between the Elders and frontline ministry leaders.
Focus Areas:
Direction: Is the program moving toward its intended purpose and advancing the mission, vision, and values of Mayflower Church?
Health: Are participants and leaders experiencing spiritual vitality?
Scope of impact: Who is being reached and served?
Growth: Are people growing spiritually and relationally?
Changed lives: What stories of transformation can we celebrate?
Phase 4: Adaptation (Re-Planning)
Use the simple Keep/Stop/Start framework:
Keep: What is working well and should continue?
Stop: What is not bearing fruit or creating unnecessary burden?
Start: What new approaches should we try based on what we've learned?
Practical Evaluation Tools
Tool 1: Simple Color-Coding System
Rate each focus area (Direction, Health, Impact, Growth, Changed Lives) using a traffic light system:
After rating, discuss: "Why did you vote the way you voted?"
Tool 2: Relational Checkup Questions
Use these questions in one-on-one or small group conversations:
What stories of life change have you witnessed in this program?
How are people experiencing God through this ministry?
What relationships are being built or strengthened?
Where do you see joy in this ministry? Where is joy lacking?
What barriers are preventing people from growing spiritually?
Are leaders empowered to use their gifts and make decisions?
What would need to change for this program to be more effective?
Is this program sustainable with current resources?
Recommended Evaluation Timeline
What Success Looks Like
A successful evaluation process demonstrates these qualities:
Leaders look forward to evaluation: It feels encouraging rather than burdensome
Stories are shared: Conversations focus on testimonies of life change, not just statistics
Decisions improve: Evaluation leads to concrete actions that enhance ministry effectiveness
Freedom increases: Leaders feel empowered to adapt and innovate based on what they learn
Health is prioritized: Sustainability and joy are valued alongside impact and growth
It stays simple: The process remains manageable and doesn't create bureaucracy
Additional Resources
Dennis Bakke's Philosophy:
Joy at Work: A Revolutionary Approach to Fun on the Job by Dennis W. Bakke
Book summary available at: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/362307.Joy_at_Work
Author website: https://dennisbakke.com/summary/
Church Program Evaluation Resources:
Program Evaluation in Church Context: https://churchconsulting.org/program-evaluation-in-church-context-forerunner-to-effective-church-consulting/
Responsive Leadership Year-End Evaluation: https://research.lifeway.com/2023/12/11/responsive-leadership-a-year-end-evaluation-for-your-church/
Ministry Evaluation Form Templates: https://www.vancopayments.com/egiving/blog/church-ministry-evaluation-form
Tool for Evaluating Ministry Programs: https://network.crcna.org/topic/church-administration/church-admin-finance/tool-evaluating-ministry-programs
Relational Ministry Approaches:
5 Elements of Relational Ministry: https://studentministry.lifeway.com/2020/05/29/5-elements-of-relational-ministry/
4 Frameworks for Church Service Review: https://unseminary.com/4-frameworks-for-church-service-review-meetings-and-20-evaluation-questions/
Case Studies:
Christ's Church of the Valley Success Story: https://workplaces.org/articles/christs-church-of-the-valley-case-study-trust-teamwork-and-transformation
Pastoral Coaching Case Study: https://convergenceus.org/case-study-1/
◆ ◆ ◆
Remember: The goal is not perfect evaluation, but faithful stewardship
of the ministries entrusted to us for God's glory and people's good.
/Users/antonbrown/Library/CloudStorage/GoogleDrive-anton@mayflowerkingston.org/Shared drives/Leadership Pipeline/Program Evaluations/Mayflower Church Program Evaluation Framework.docx